Crew, Training Mistakes Cited in Accident Report
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) reported that the probable cause of an accident involving the cruise ship Crown Princess was the second officer's incorrect wheel commands, executed first to counter an unanticipated high rate of turn and then to counter the vessel's heeling. Contributing to the cause of the accident were the captain's and staff captain's inappropriate inputs to the vessel's integrated navigation system while it was traveling at high speed in relatively shallow water, their failure to stabilize the vessel's heading fluctuations before leaving the bridge, and the inadequate training of crewmembers in the use of integrated navigation systems. "We see from this accident the importance of having adequate training," said NTSB Mark V. Rosenker. "Had the crew been better trained in the equipment they were using, this accident may not have occurred, and implementing our recommendations is one way to help ensure this." On July 18, 2006, the cruise ship Crown Princess, which had been in service about a month, departed Port Canaveral, Florida, for Brooklyn, NY, its last port on a 10-day round trip voyage to the Caribbean. About an hour after departing, the vessel's automatic navigation system caused the ship's heading to fluctuate around its intended course. Alarmed by a perceived high rate of turn, the second officer attempted to take corrective action that resulted in the ship heeling to a maximum angle of about 24 degrees to starboard. This caused people to be thrown about or struck by unsecured objects, resulting in 14 serious and 284 minor injuries to passengers and crewmembers. The vessel incurred no damage to its structure but sustained considerable damage to unsecured interior components, cabinets, and their contents. The report adopted by the Board states that the Crown Princess was operating at nearly full speed when the second officer took the controls. Because of instabilities in the automatic steering system, the officer faced the problem of navigating a vessel that exhibited both increasing course deviations and high rates of turn. The second officer took manual control of the steering and steered back and forth between port and starboard in increasingly wider turns. Rather than remedying the problem, the second officer's actions aggravated the situation, resulting in a very large angle of heel. The captain quickly returned to the bridge and brought the vessel under control by centering the rudder and reducing speed. The Safety
February 2008
Board concluded that the incident occurred because the second officer initially turned the wheel to port, when he should have turned it to starboard to counteract the turn. The Safety Board also said that the captain and staff captain made errors, including:
� Failure to recognize that the integrated navigation system could be unpredictable at high speed in shallow water. � Failure to recognize that the rudder economy and rudder limit settings on
the integrated navigation system were inappropriate for the vessel's speed and operating conditions. The Board concluded that these errors stemmed from inadequate training and lack of familiarity with the integrated navigation system.
The widest range of marine equipment
EMS Ship Supply
Saves you time
Product range Tank ventilation fans Lifeboats Rescue boats Ship and rig davits Pneumatic fenders Oily water separating systems Breathing air compressors Working air compressors Air dryers and filters Freshwater maker systems (RO) FRS equipment High pressure cleaning Hold cleaning and protection chemicals Cargo hold cleaning equipment Eurospares
Visit us at the CMA exhibition, stand no. 83
Provider of and products
Our other offices: Norway The Netherlands Germany Singapore France Spain Greece Turkey UK China
Eitzen Maritime Services ASA
Your global partner with a local presence
EMS Ship Supply (USA) 12 Talcott Range Drive. East Granby, CT 06026, USA Tel: +1 860 653 9461, Fax: +1 860 653 9457 shipsupply.us@ems-asa.com, www.ems-shipsupply.com
THE SPECIALISTS IN MARITIME SECURITY
Securewest International is a worldwide specialist maritime provider of security services to commercial, cruise, government shipping and port facilities. Security Officers are all former armed forces personnel maritime trained, providing security services worldwide on short or long term contract. Maritime Security Officers Cruise Ship Qualified Ship Security Officers Approved SSAS monitoring and management ISPS/MTSA Assessments, Plans Drills and Exercises MCA and DNV/MARAD Approved ISPS/MTSA Training courses
SM
SECUREWEST INTERNATIONAL
Maritime Security Specialists since 1987
+44 (0)1548 856001 +1 757 461 4343 24 hour service: +1 757 461 4343 info@securewest.com www.securewest.com
UK Office: USA Office:
Principal offices in the UK, USA and Singapore
www.marinelink.com
29